Vienna archdiocesan re-structuring provokes many questions

Cardinal Christoph Schönborn, Archbishop of Vienna, has announced a major restructuring of the diocese. Within the next 10 years, 660 parishes will be amalgamated into 150. The shortage of priests and declining numbers of Catholics is cited as the reason.

The situation in Vienna gives us much to ponder. On the one hand, Cardinal Schönborn praises the role of the laity in his vision of a restructured church. When I first read these paragraphs in the NCR article, I confess that my heart skipped a joyful beat,

“I am fully aware that these reforms denote a far-reaching change of perspective,” Schönborn said. “We must take leave of the traditional concept that the church is only present where there is a priest. That is a restricted view that has developed over time but which must now be corrected. Church is community, and leading offices in the church should in principle be carried out collaboratively, even if the parish priest has the final responsibility according to canon law.”

The “common priesthood of all the baptized” will take center stage from now on, Schönborn said, meaning that those who have been baptized and confirmed will be responsible for evangelization and pastoral work. The reform is meant to bring about a new form of cooperation between priests and lay Catholics based on their common vocation to Christianity, he said.

Amen! Now, you’re talking. Granted, it’s rather sad that this is acknowledged only when the kaka hits the fan and reality seems to leaves you no choice. Still, this is what church should be. A high ranking cardinal is empowering the laity to take a more active and collaborative role. This is good! So, how is it going to work?

Several priests — “at least three to five” — would be active in each of the central parishes and would run the parish jointly with lay parishioners.

“Participatory leadership with clear task allocation” was the aim, Schönborn said. One priest in each of the central parishes would be responsible to the archbishop.

Within these large central parishes, there would be many small affiliated communities run only by lay Catholics who would work voluntarily. The cardinal expressly emphasized that no parishes would be closed, but smaller parishes might be amalgamated with larger ones.

Catholics would have to travel to one of the large central parishes to celebrate the Eucharist, but Services of the Word would be celebrated by the laypeople running the local affiliated communities.

Church activities would be dedicated to evangelization to a far greater extent than they had been up to now, Schönborn said.

“More and more vibrant communities will be able to develop,” he said, as there would be less administrative work, costs would be bundled, resources pooled and thus “more time left for evangelization.”

Okay, now it doesn’t look so rosy. Living in the rural prairies, I know how difficult it is when a small, mission parish must shut down. I know the difficulty that many families face when they have to travel many miles to attend a Sunday Liturgy. I know what it is like to have no priest on a Sunday and celebrate an occasional lay-led Liturgy of the Word. So far, we have survived. But, what if all our rural parishes were closed in favour of mega-churches in the cities and larger towns? It could happen one day.

The need for ordained, sacramental ministers is not addressed by merely amalgamating parishes. These reforms are being criticized by the Catholic reform group Austrian Priests’ Initiative, which is in favor of ordaining married men and women to relieve the shortage of priests.

So, is the answer to open the doors to the priesthood, or to open wider the doors for more active lay participation? Of course, this does not need to be an either-or question. Doing both might be the logical response for the current needs.

But, if lay women and men are expected to do the administrative and pastoral work previously done by the priest, then they should NOT have to do it as volunteers.  Personally, I find it cheeky of the good Cardinal to propose this while promoting the cost savings of his amalgamation plan. The church has many women and men who are highly educated in theology and pastoral ministry. We should expect a certain level of experience, training or qualifications from lay pastoral ministers, and pay them accordingly – a proper and just living wage not a nominal stipend.

This is going to be an important story to watch. We have heard dire warnings of priest shortages and shrinking parishes for years. For some, this isn’t bad news. Zealous souls on the left have often shared their eagerness for the church to implode. Only then, they believe, could much desired reform rise, phoenix-like, out of the ashes of a tired and spent hierarchy. They are waiting in the wings and on the margins, eager to lead a lay revolution in the church.

Sometimes we have to be careful what we wish for. The situation in Vienna is proof that the future may be closer than we think.Grandiose visions and exuberant battle cries can easily vaporize in the harshness of reality. It’s easy to talk from the margins. It’s much harder to be working from the inside. Are we, as lay women and men, really ready to take true responsibility of our church’s mission in the world? Am I? Are you?

8 thoughts on “Vienna archdiocesan re-structuring provokes many questions

      • Hi Curtis,
        There is certainly a need for creativity, for that wonderful Vatican II call to carefully discern the signs of the times. And, new times need new methods. Here’s hoping….

      • Joseph Builds A New Home. ( idea in progress) appreciate your comments
        © Curtis L Biggar
        Joseph & Jesus return to earth to experience the condition of the kingdom on earth as it exists today.
        They choose America because it best acknowledges & practices the freedoms that come from God.
        Imagine the experiences Joseph shared with Jesus during the dozen or so years they worked together as
        a carpenters & artisans building or remodeling homes around Narezeth, before Jesus began his pubic
        ministry. Bring this story forward to tell of the design & construction of a new home in
        Wisconsin,where hearts can grow & where a christian family can form the foundation for refining the
        world, a place to discuss solutions to sensitive issues that challenge & threaten our families & the
        world today.
        Imagine Joseph & his young apprentice checking out the “green movement”, global warming;
        conservation of energy; air & water quality; recycling and other efforts protecting creation as they
        build a modest house that God could bless. They find wonderful new materials & building techniques;
        unimaginable market places for tools & supplies. Walk with them on their first trip to Home Depot.
        Joseph gets a copy of the National Green Building Standard & studies it with Jesus. They come to the
        conclusion that humans have the capacity to develop codes that respect nature & create a basis for the
        future built environment. Many people really care………
        Ch I excerpts
        Joseph & his apprentice son Jesus revisit N. E Wisconsin to build an ideal home that would accommodate
        a contemporary family that lives a holy lifestyle similar to what their family life enjoyed 2000 years
        ago, but using knowledge gained since their time…………
        Ch II excerpts
        Always respectful of the law, Joseph begins searching zoning & building codes. He also looks at the state
        of art in the construction industry and the present use of natural resources……………..
        Ch III excerpts
        Jesus looks at the current condition of the environment that is of grave concern following two centuries
        of population growth throughout the planet. He finds a divided society over the sources & production of
        energy to sustain homes and related support facilities………..
        Ch IV excerpts
        Joseph is Amazed at worldwide communication & transportation systems that bring cultures together
        and also cause great conflict even in their mid east homeland……
        Ch v excerpts
        Joseph reviews american census statistics & finds strange contrasts in actual extant national home
        inventory versus practical family needs. He sees extreme excesses in contrast to minimal standards of
        comfort. This is nothing new to Joseph…………………..
        Ch VI excerpts
        Joseph asks Jesus to check out Google, Linkedin, Amazon and other internet information sites that
        support the construction industry. He finds a lot more (good & bad) than that, but realizes that God can
        process all the internet information in the blink of an eye…………………

  1. Isabella, thank you for this article. A picture of what is to come for most of us and our parishes, I suspect. While in college 35 years ago, I was certain that ordination would be opened to women and married men. Crazy of me, huh? What we are seeing instead are the effects of church leadership, heels dug in, resisting any change. It seems they prefer to have fewer priests and work them to death rather than consider opening up ordination. Even with the many educated and trained lay people in the church, the reality is the priest still has the final say. Collaboration may be defined quite differently by the hierarchy than the lay person. I think the process that led to the new Roman Missal is proof of that.

    Is it possible that the shortage of priests and the exodus of so many catholics from the church will bring about real change? A new openness to real collaboration, inclusion, and opportunity for all: women, men, gay, straight among others? Are we finally reaching a point where change MUST happen and we will be renewed in a new church with new and wonderful possibilities, where new life will be breathed into all of us?
    God, I hope so.

    By the way, how are things going with your new priest? What became of the discussion on mass times? Just wondering!

    Thanks for a doing a great job of challenging your readers. It is a bright spot for me.

    Anthony Lehmann

  2. Hi Anthony,
    I agree with you. We are coming upon a real ‘crunch’ time in our church. Many have blithely said ‘bring it on’, with the hopes that real reform can finally take place. But, it really IS a wake up call to us all to take responsibility for our church. We need to stop waiting for pastors and bishops to take the initiative, and grumbling if they don’t. We need to be visioning this together…and then collaborating on making the vision happen.

    Joining you in the hoping…..

    Isabella

  3. Oooops….forgot to answer your question about the new pastor, Anthony. (Again, this is not our home parish) We visited the parish again a couple of weeks ago. The Sunday mass times have been changed to answer the needs of the parish (a 7:00 pm Sunday night mass to accommodate workers). The pastor also gave the best homily I have ever heard on sacramental marriage….encouraging those of us who are in ‘well’ marriages not to judge those who have experienced the break down of relationships. The homily was a keeper…..I wish I took notes. 😉

Comments are closed.